Thanks for the suggestions. Unfortunately no matter what kind of treat is in front of her in the car with or without the windshield wipers she won't touch it. I did start only taking her in the car when it wasn't raining and was trying to get her comfortable in the car without the windshield wipers again. However I no longer have access to a car so Tiger Lilly isn't doing many car rides. She has done a few bus rides and has done really well. She even took a treat once while in the bus. Her anxiety and shaking has settled so I'm hoping that once she's in a car again that'll continue and she'll realize that windshield wipers aren't so scary

.